Documentary: #Oscar Edith + Eddie #Short

This short shred my heart into a million pieces.  I was sobbing throughout.  Having taken care of my Dad, elder care is a subject that hits close to my heart as it is.  I wrote this on the night of the 20th.  I will go back on the 21st and inevitably make changes. I wrote, backspaced, wrote again.  This documentary brought out more feelings that I thought possible in a short 30 minutes.  Anger, bitterness, doubt, despair.  All the bad emotions mixed on one big batch.

There are those people who will say they are acting in the best interest of an elder person.  Sometimes they are.  Sometimes they think they are.  Sometimes they are not.  I have never wanted to reach through a screen to strangle a person as much as I did Jessica Niesen.  I looked her up just now.  She is still a lawyer who is an expert in elder care.  I guess expertise is in the eye of the beholder.  The court placed her as the guardian of a woman she never met in person, never knew on a personal level, only knew her paperwork.  This woman never met Edith in person until the night she ripped her out of her own home and away from her husband.  This story played out a couple of years ago, the documentary was released last year.  This woman is still a practicing attorney.  Is there no outrage for the injustice of elder care?  Or does the law of the land lean toward injustice?  The kicker, after Eddie’s death (where Edith was not allowed to come say goodbye), Niesen became responsible for his remains.  The end of the documentary states that to this day, a service or memorial had never been arranged.  ((seethe))

I put everything I had to getting my Dad back on his feet, getting him back home and to the healthiest version of himself.  He had open heart surgery, five hours from his loved ones because the VA is flawed and lacks communication that would be beneficial to the families of loved ones requiring services. While in Richmond, after his surgery, he went into cardiac arrest.  From that event he had hypoxia (lack of oxygen to the brain).  He went from the hospital to a nursing home to a second nursing home.  From that nursing home, after a series of miracles, he went home for three years until he became very ill and succumb to an array of illnesses in my home, in a hospital bed in my sunroom.

There was a woman in my Father’s life who (in my opinion) took advantage of him.  He bought her dinners, took her places, paid the tabs (I managed his money, I saw the checks and debit card transactions).  She, in turn, told him that she did not want him to be an “official boyfriend” (Dad’s words, not mine), just a friend who had fun (also Dad’s words).  Dad and I had conversations about it.  He knew I did not like her, we spoke of it.  He knew that she said horrible things to my kids, we had conversations about it.  She knew we collectively disliked her.  She wore whore red high heels and a whore dress to his wake.  I suppose she was making a statement.  In whore clothes, it would be hard not to.  Dad would lament the passing of my Ma and talk about how he missed her and that this woman was no replacement, just company.  It is my opinion (and having been told details from others) that she had more than one “friend” who bought dinners and paid for things.  On one occasion she called members of our family to tell them that Daddy was at her house, had taken too much insulin and someone needed to come get him because she had to go show a house (she was a realtor).  I seethe now because the one person in Dad’s family who was this woman’s friend never told me that detail.  The only thing I was told was that Dad had over dosed his insulin.  I found out after, after he was gone.  People are assholes.  They really are.  Self righteous assholes.  I state these facts because watching the love that Edith + Eddie shared, in my humble opinion, was a genuine gift at their age.  To have someone at that stage of  your life care for you and you return those feelings – what an amazing gift.  And that gift was not honored in this case by one daughter nor the guardian the court assigned to Edith.

When I received the call that we needed to prepare ourselves, that we needed to make decisions about end of life care for Dad, I never thought once about making sure everyone was there in the room with the doctors to offer their input.  I trongly guided the conversation because it was my intention to bring my Dad to my home to die, not put him away in a hospice facility just because it was convenient for one or two people to maybe visit him for a few minutes at their convenience.  I fought for that right.  Dad used to call me his pitbull, fighting for him at every turn.  I wanted him to be in our home, surrounded by loved ones, close enough that my Sister could come visit and have a place to stay if she wanted.  I refused to consider a hospice facility, as that woman found out when she mentioned it in my presence.  I had the room, I had the resources, my boss was kind enough to offer me the time.  I told all of those present that I would open my home to have an early Thanksgiving, give me a handful of days to prepare, and everyone could come to my house, stay in my home, whether we liked each other or not.  I stated that I would let my step-brother, who I have never been on good terms with, come to my home and I would have my husband there to greet him and I would remove myself from the situation so he could say goodbye to his Dad.  I certainly didn’t do it for my love of these people, but for my Dad’s love of his family.  That is what you do if you truly love someone.  You remove your feelings from it all and do what is best for your loved one.  That one Sister cared for her Mother (Edith) and the other sister took their Mom out of the only house she ever knew and then refused to allow the caregiver Sister to see her Mom before she passed – is criminal.  And Jessica Niesen facilitated that.  And did not facilitate a memorial service for Edith’s husband, Eddie.  I just cannot.  At all.

This 30 minute documentary brought out all of my bitterness for the assholes in life that care only about being right above the person they are supposed to love.  It brought to the surface all of my feelings, all of my many many feelings.  It reminded me of the frustration I felt at trying to organize my Dad’s finances and blindly trying to do my best to include people I felt aided in my Dad’s demise.  Every. Feeling. Felt.

I know my intention is to review the documentary.  I have only one line: It rebroke me.

The whole documentary:

IMDB page: HERE 



  1. This really was such s heartbreaker. Like other commentors, I’ve watched the ugliness, greed &/or plain indifference come out in people as relatives aged. Also a now-retired attorney, but never practiced guardianship (although I know several who do). First & most importantly, I was a granddaughter to a financially & emotionally abused grandmother (same with her second husband, who was such a true lifesaver to her after my grandfather passed) & then a daughter to a physically & emotionally abused father in an “assisted living facility” (HA!) & lastly, a daughter to a mother whose mild dementia developed into extreme Alzheimer’s. In each instance, sickening, greedy relatives couldn’t wait to get their hands on bank accounts & property. Each time, the ill & aging relative was trapped by “family” who were really only counting the minutes – and the dollars. I’ve set up my own affairs to take any temptation out of the equation for my own family, but only because I’ve seen the worst possibilities. As for the court appointed guardians: some can be at least trustworthy & dutiful (albeit for a hefty fee), while others are soul-less (pre)grave robbers; easy pickings. SO much needs to change in the law. The plain fact is that it’s too easy to abuse elders & litigation to try to step in is incredibly expensive in addition to being emotionally fraught.

  2. On one end I thought that I was watching a beautiful love story, then it turned into a dark hell. Pure wickedness and evil. Ms. Jessica, you are one of the most disgusting people I’ve ever heard of in my life. As a mandated reporter, was the alleged abuse investigated? Do you regularly tell lies? Vacation? Bull crap! He can call her? Bull crap! She’ll be back in two weeks? More bull crap! May I ask, who raised you? A pack of wolves, in sheep clothing I bet. You should never work in that field again! Shame on you and I wish no good comes to you as a result of what you did.

  3. Jessica only wanted to get paid and didn’t see anything behind the harm what was done. I hope she loses her clientele over what she did. The fact that she did not give this man a proper funeral blows my mind. Edith’s evil daughter who kept her away from her other sister and her husband should be ashamed of herself as well. Jessica didn’t seem to have a care in the world about them when she showed up and how she spoke to them was awful. My heart goes out to the daughter who took care of her mom and these two love birds. Rest in heaven! We all know you are together now.

  4. Jessica Niesen is the epitome of guardian from hell. Some state guardians are in it for the money…you cannot get more cold hearted that this woman. She will have to live with this for ripping a happy couple apart and ruining their happiness and lives. Clearly she has no compassion and should not be a guardian!! Omg. Horrible human being.

  5. I know this may be a black mark on my heart and soul, but I sincerely hope Karma pays a long and painful visit to this so-called “caregiver’s” life. Long. And. Painful.

  6. Jessica Niesen, your actions in this case were cruel, racist, and amoral. From what I know, the only way you continue in your profession, it seems to me, is due to others who share the same racist and careless views. You reap what you soe.

  7. I hate this lady Jessica Niesen….WTF!!!! Thought I was watching a sweet love story. Turned out to be the most disturbing story in a very long time.

    How could she lie to this man and not bring his wife back. She killed him.

    I bet she care more for a 4 legged pet animals than two 95+ human beings who made it this far.

    Tried fast forwarding hoping to get to the good part because I couldn’t believe what I was watching.

    Smh…ruined our night

    1. I watched this documentary as part of a “Oscars Watch” I was doing last year. It was nominated. It devastated my heart! Horrible freaking woman.

      1. I cannot express enough in my own words how much this review “hit home” for me. Exactly. Reopened wounds from my fiancees’ passing because I also went through a very similar experience with his family and lets just say I was accepted and loved for over a decade and then as his terminal illness worsened, I turned into the mortal enemy. Just watching this documentary broke my heart all over again. I’m really upset right now. Edith & Eddie deserved better from Jessica the “expert attorney in elder law/care and from Edith’s daughter living in Florida. All I do know wholeheartedly is that no matter how awful people treat me, I will never, ever let go of my huge heart and will never bring myself to their level. Karma and Hell are two of the many things rotten people have going for them. I know in my heart, I gave my fiancee my everything in those months, and that’s what is important.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.